Best Pizza in Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY

Experience Classic New York-Style Pizza With Italian Flavor in Every Bite

Order online

Featured

View menu

Cowboy Slice (Chicken Bacon Ranch)

White Slice

Sicilian Slice

Chicken Cutlet Hero

Grilled Chicken Caesar Wrap

Welcome to Tony’s Brooklyn Pizza

Nestled in the heart of Williamsburg at 355 Graham Avenue, Tony’s Brooklyn Pizza has been serving authentic New York-style pizza since 1950. Enjoy a wide variety of classic slices, deep-dish pan pizza, fresh pasta, calzones, and Italian appetizers, all made with high-quality ingredients. Whether you’re grabbing a quick slice or indulging in a full Italian meal, our warm, inviting atmosphere makes every visit a true Brooklyn experience.

Delicious Pizza and Italian Favorites

At Tony’s Brooklyn Pizza, every bite is a celebration of authentic New York flavors. From classic thin-crust slices and hearty deep-dish pan pizza to fresh pasta, calzones, and stromboli, our menu offers something for every craving. Enjoy Italian appetizers like stuffed mushrooms, baked clams, and garlic bread, or savor hot and cold sandwiches made with premium ingredients. Finish your meal with espresso and fresh Italian pastries for a true Brooklyn dining experience.

Explore Our Menu

Order Your Favorites Online

Enjoy authentic New York-style pizza and Italian classics with just a few clicks. Our website makes it easy to browse the full menu, from classic slices and deep-dish pan pizza to calzones, pasta, and fresh Italian pastries. Whether you’re at home, at work, or in Williamsburg, your favorite meal is ready for quick pickup or delivery straight to your door.

Order Now

Our Delicious Creations

Discover our menu favorites, from classic New York-style slices and deep-dish pizza to fresh pasta, calzones, and Italian appetizers. Every dish is made with high-quality ingredients and authentic flavors, bringing the taste of Brooklyn to every bite.

Authentic Brooklyn Dining

Step into Tony’s Brooklyn Pizza and feel the heart of Williamsburg. Since 1950, Tony’s has served classic New York-style slices in a warm, welcoming atmosphere with friendly, attentive service. Enjoy fresh pizza, Italian appetizers, calzones, pasta, and pastries while soaking in the lively, neighborhood vibe that makes every meal memorable. Tony’s isn’t just pizza—it’s a true Brooklyn experience.

Read About Us

Bring Tony’s to Your Next Event

Make your next gathering unforgettable with Tony’s Brooklyn Pizza catering. Since 1950, we’ve been serving authentic New York-style pizza, Italian appetizers, calzones, pasta, and more—all made with fresh, high-quality ingredients. From office lunches and birthday parties to family celebrations, our friendly team ensures timely delivery, setup, and a delicious spread that everyone will love. Taste the best of Brooklyn, wherever you are.

What our guests are saying

Sweet staff members who made us feel so welcomed. I got the chicken bacon slice with chicken noodle soup. Both are stellar. Highly recommend. The retro decor was a plus as well

Angela Z.

Sometimes you just want an old school slice of pizza. Tony's is the go-to for that. I had a Sicilian & dare I say it was so good, I almost got a 2nd slice. Fast service, GREAT pizza, & that old school pizza joint vibe. No complaints!

Khola W.

Service was excellent— love ordering NY pizza from a spot where you hear “see ya later Paulie” from a regular as they leave the shop. The vibes inside are awesome, almost cinematic.